Let me make one thing clear: I'm from Northeast Ohio, and in the rust
belt, you just don't pay much for anything. In Akron, a
post-industrial rubber town, it's possible to have a decent middle-class
life (including house and car) for $70,000 a year. I know a couple who
bought a home for $60,000 and are living quite happily as musicians with
a single full-time income. Fairlawn now seems like a magical land to
me, because you can get discount groceries at Marc's and in 5 minutes be
at the Mustard Seed picking out a bunch of organic kale - which would
take all day in the city. Or, on a Saturday, jog up Smith Road to
Akron-Peninsula and hit the Farmers' Market. You can get high-quality
jeans at TJ Max and in 15 minutes be at the Village Thrift snatching up
Summit County's best vintage sweaters for $3 a piece. I never realized
how truly amazing this was until I moved to Toronto.
Don't get me
wrong, Toronto is amazing. But living here challenges my American
"standards" as a consumer. And I'm not alone - Canadians cross the
border frequently to buy clothes, electronics and even food in the U.S..
Even though they have to pay duty when crossing the border, they still
find it cheaper to shop Stateside. Here are some examples of sticker
shock I've had since moving here:
Organic Eggs: $7.59/doz ($3.99 at the Mustard Seed Market in Akron)
House: $503,094 ($155,681 in NEO, according to
this article)
1-bedroom apartment: $905/month ($450-600 in NEO)
Auto insurance: $1231/year
By
these figures you can start to see that being middle class in Toronto
might not look the same as it does in Akron, Kent or Cleveland. This is
especially so considering that the median income for Toronto is lower
than in surrounding suburbs like Brampton or Peterboro. Sean and I don't
expect to buy a house here for awhile, if ever. Not that I'm
complaining. I feel quite happy being with my sweetie in a world-class
city. I'm just tripping on all the little differences in standard of
living.
This is all pretty tongue-in-cheek though, since I know
full well that cheap goods come at a price, ethically. And I recognize
that I grew up in a time when interest on credit was at an all-time low.
I walked into freshman orientation in 1999 and was literally handed a
credit card application. So to me, it's quite normal to be able to have
what I want, when I want it. Sean, on the other hand,
cringes when
he has to "charge it". And for good reason: interest rates in Canada
are around 19.9%. Shocking? Perhaps, but Canadians seem to view debt in a
healthier way because of it.
The un-availability of
media is also surprising. Again, I came of age in a time when digital
entertainment was becoming more and more available. Napster, bit
torrent, and finally iTunes, allowed cheap or free access to music. I'm
used to Hulu, Netflix, Spotify, Amazon instant downloads, the plummeting
cost of books and magazine subscriptions - non of which, mind you, is a
sign of economic health. But I still feel a little jilted by the
disappointing selection on Canadian Netflix, the high cost of greeting
cards, and the fact that I can't watch New Girl on demand. If you want
media here, you pay.
I guess I was so busy being infuriated
by right-wing politics and high-fructose corn syrup, that I failed to
appreciate living in the pop culture mecca of the world. The United
States has been grinding out intellectual and entertainment product for
decades; one only has to listen to a news piece about the Juno Awards to
confirm the U.S. is still the gold standard in entertainment. And since
the U.S. have the sole right to screw over its own recording artists
and print media, sometimes it's free!
On the other hand, my
American (read middle-class suburban) standards are being blown away in
good ways, too. There's a much higher concentration of everything,
including farm markets, good restaurants, and locally-owned businesses.
Investigative journalism seems a bit less like a thing of the past. And
of course, Canada is known (so far) for having more sensible priorities
and a more humanitarian climate than the U.S., which I hope won't be
changing too soon.
While I get over the sticker shock of living
in Canada, I'm fortunate to have a supportive husband, a few low-budget
hobbies like writing and yoga, and a good head for money. But really,
there's much more to standard of living than the cheap prices, and
that's what makes Toronto worthwhile.